Javascript is required to view this map.

Top 23 expert-rated hotels in New York City

By Ondine Cohane, your New York City expert

Sort by

#1/23
expert-rated hotels
Expert overall rating:4.9 (out of 5)
Right in the heart of Soho - one of New York's best hotelsRead more »
Average price: £329
#2/23
expert-rated hotels
No image
Expert overall rating:4.9 (out of 5)
A boutique hotel charmer in the heart of downtownRead more »
Average price: £315
#3/23
expert-rated hotels
No image
Expert overall rating:4.5 (out of 5)
A happening property that's a stone's throw from Chelsea and Meatpacking areaRead more »
Average price: £100
#4/23
expert-rated hotels
Expert overall rating:4.5 (out of 5)
A trendy but service friendly downtown gemRead more »
Average price: £305
#5/23
expert-rated hotels
Expert overall rating:3.3 (out of 5)
An affordable stylish boutique hotel in Midtown, it's the perfect location to explore the city.Read more »
Average price: £104
#6/23
expert-rated hotels
Expert overall rating:3.2 (out of 5)
One of the best bargains in Manhattan in one of its most charming neighborhoods.Read more »
Average price: £50
Average price: £56
Average price: £60
Average price: £250
Average price: £180
Average price: £175
Average price: £200
Average price: £177
Average price: £270
Average price: £385
Average price: £414
Average price: £139
Average price: £314
Showing 1-20 of 23 results
Set focus

I've been reviewing hotels in New York for over a decade for travel publications and to keep my choices up to date when friends and family come looking for a recommendation.

My picks for Simonseeks run the gamut from the best luxury spots the city has to offer, to stylish boutique hotels that have sprung up in the last few years, to cheap but still chic establishments. Most importantly the hotels I have picked are ones that I like to stay in myself.

* Simonseeks has given star ratings out of five for all accommodation recommendations. With hotels, these will tally with the hotel's official star rating where it exists. Where a hotel has no official star rating, and in the case of b & bs and hostels, the experts have made a judgment as to how many stars the accommodation deserves, in terms of comfort, level of facilities and so forth.

How I’ve picked my hotels: 

The New York hotel scene has never been more favorable for travelers.

In 2010, 40 new hotels will debut in New York City at a time when bookings aren’t nearly as strong as they once were and there are many more rooms on the market.

That means great deals, especially for savvy shoppers willing to shop around and travel off peak (avoid Christmas, Easter and all of the American holidays like Memorial Day weekend (the last week of May), July 4th, Martin Luther King Jr weekend in January and Presidents’ Day weekend in February, for example).

Ask about two for the price of three night offers, special rates and weekend deals—most property rates fall on Friday to Monday nights when business travelers head home.

And it’s not just the bargains, especially compared to a few years back, that are such a draw; it’s the dizzying array of kinds of hotels that have cropped up in the last decade. So much so that whenever I come back I stay in one or two hotels myself because they each give me such a different take on the city than staying in an apartment. Whether it’s a hip boutique hotel, a newly revamped grand dame, an intimate small pad or palatial digs overlooking Central Park, there really is something for every taste and budget. So start planning your trip.

Set focus

The New York hotel scene has never been more favorable for travelers.

In 2010, 40 new hotels will debut in New York City at a time when bookings aren’t nearly as strong as they once were and there are many more rooms on the market.

That means great deals, especially for savvy shoppers willing to shop around and travel off peak (avoid Christmas, Easter and all of the American holidays like Memorial Day weekend (the last week of May), July 4th, Martin Luther King Jr weekend in January and Presidents’ Day weekend in February, for example).

Ask about two for the price of three night offers, special rates and weekend deals—most property rates fall on Friday to Monday nights when business travelers head home.

And it’s not just the bargains, especially compared to a few years back, that are such a draw; it’s the dizzying array of kinds of hotels that have cropped up in the last decade. So much so that whenever I come back I stay in one or two hotels myself because they each give me such a different take on the city than staying in an apartment. Whether it’s a hip boutique hotel, a newly revamped grand dame, an intimate small pad or palatial digs overlooking Central Park, there really is something for every taste and budget. So start planning your trip.